Shimano Catana FE 4000 HGX vs Daiwa 23 Caldia SW 10000-HX

The selected categories are different, score metrics vary from category to another.

Shimano Catana FE

Spinning

53.70 out of 100

Value for money3.5 out of 5

Quality classLow

Durability2.74 out of 10

Ergonomics4 out of 10

Gear ratio5.8:1

Maximum drag8.5kg / 18,74lbs

Weight320g / 11.29oz

Line retireve per crank93 centimeter / 36.61 inch

Ball bearings3+1

Technical Specifications

BrandSHIMANO
The main category of the reelSpinning
Price range~ €34.33
Is saltwater resistantNo
Spare spoolNo
Reel size4000 HG
Handle typeSingle handle
Drag typeFront drag
Handle orientationLeft, Right
Line capacity monofilmm/meter: 0.3/180

Daiwa 23 Caldia SW

Seafishing

67.20 out of 100

Value for money4 out of 5

Quality classGood

Durability8.79 out of 10

Ergonomics5.48 out of 10

Gear ratio5.7:1

Maximum drag15kg / 33.07lbs

Weight645g / 22.75oz

Line retireve per crank121 centimeter / 47.64 inch

Ball bearings6+1

Technical Specifications

BrandDAIWA
The main category of the reelSeafishing
Price range~ €237.33
Is saltwater resistantYes
Spare spoolNo
Reel size10000-H
Handle typeSingle handle
Drag typeFront drag
Handle orientationLeft, Right
Line capacity monofilmm/meter: 0.33/300

Conclusion

Daiwa 23 Caldia SW 10000-HX edges out Shimano Catana FE 4000 HGX with slightly better overall performance, especially on the durability (8.79 out of 10) and the weight (645g / 22,75oz). Still, Shimano Catana FE 4000 HGX holds its own with strengths like a gear ratio of 5.8:1 and a line retrieve per crank of 93 centimeter / 36.61 inch, making it a solid choice depending on your preferences and fishing needs.

What's the difference between Shimano Catana FE and Daiwa 23 Caldia SW?

Shimano Catana FE 4000 HGX

A fast gear ratio of 9.2 out of 10 (5.8:1), means the reel is built for speed and it's perfect for active retrieves, and quick follow ups
8.8 out of 10 (93 centimeter / 36.61 inch) in line retrieve, means it picks up line fast, very handy when chasing quick fish

Daiwa 23 Caldia SW 10000-HX

Scoring 8.16 out of 10 (645g / 22,75oz), this reel is lighter than expected for a saltwater model, which helps on long sessions without extra strain
Built tough for the salt, ideal for seafishing.